Is an isobar the same as an isotope?
up vote
19
down vote
favorite
I am a little bit confused about what an isobar is. Its online definition is that it's an element with the same number of neutrons but a different number of protons from an element $ce{X}$.
To me, it doesn't make sense from the get-go, because once you change the number of protons the element changes as well so why exactly is it defined as the same element $ce{X}$ with the same number of neutrons and a different number of protons.
Definition of an isotope: An isotope is an element $ce{X}$ with the same number of protons and a different number of neutrons.
So to the actual question now. Isn't an isobar just an isotope? Here is an example to clarify what I mean.
If we take for example carbon $ce{^12C(p:6, n:6)}$ and turn it into an isotope it will be $ce{^13C(p:6, n:7)}$, and that makes sense, but if we turn it into an isobar it would be $ce{^13C(p:7, n:6)}$, which doesn't make sense, because it looks exactly like an isotope of nitrogen $ce{^13N(p:7, n:6)}$.
If the atomic number changes than the element changes as well. So isn't an isobar just an isotope of the following element with a smaller neutron number?
terminology isotope
New contributor
add a comment |
up vote
19
down vote
favorite
I am a little bit confused about what an isobar is. Its online definition is that it's an element with the same number of neutrons but a different number of protons from an element $ce{X}$.
To me, it doesn't make sense from the get-go, because once you change the number of protons the element changes as well so why exactly is it defined as the same element $ce{X}$ with the same number of neutrons and a different number of protons.
Definition of an isotope: An isotope is an element $ce{X}$ with the same number of protons and a different number of neutrons.
So to the actual question now. Isn't an isobar just an isotope? Here is an example to clarify what I mean.
If we take for example carbon $ce{^12C(p:6, n:6)}$ and turn it into an isotope it will be $ce{^13C(p:6, n:7)}$, and that makes sense, but if we turn it into an isobar it would be $ce{^13C(p:7, n:6)}$, which doesn't make sense, because it looks exactly like an isotope of nitrogen $ce{^13N(p:7, n:6)}$.
If the atomic number changes than the element changes as well. So isn't an isobar just an isotope of the following element with a smaller neutron number?
terminology isotope
New contributor
2
Related: What are compounds with the same mass called? and What are isodiaphers?
– Loong♦
yesterday
4
To me an isobar is a line on a weather chart connecting points of the same atmospheric pressure.
– Ross Millikan
yesterday
@RossMillikan Me too. Maybe because my eldest brother was a USAF meteorologist, I pay more attention to that kind of isobar. Very confusing for the same word to mean very different things in different branches of science.
– Monty Harder
23 hours ago
@MontyHarder: wiki tells me that old greek βάρος (baros) means weight en.wiktionary.org/wiki/%CE%B2%CE%AC%CF%81%CE%BF%CF%82. So the isobar = same mass/weight seems to be closer to the direct translation of the term than same pressure (which of course is the weight of the atmosphere per area) And btw. in the chart of nuclides you do have isobaric lines as well.
– cbeleites
8 hours ago
add a comment |
up vote
19
down vote
favorite
up vote
19
down vote
favorite
I am a little bit confused about what an isobar is. Its online definition is that it's an element with the same number of neutrons but a different number of protons from an element $ce{X}$.
To me, it doesn't make sense from the get-go, because once you change the number of protons the element changes as well so why exactly is it defined as the same element $ce{X}$ with the same number of neutrons and a different number of protons.
Definition of an isotope: An isotope is an element $ce{X}$ with the same number of protons and a different number of neutrons.
So to the actual question now. Isn't an isobar just an isotope? Here is an example to clarify what I mean.
If we take for example carbon $ce{^12C(p:6, n:6)}$ and turn it into an isotope it will be $ce{^13C(p:6, n:7)}$, and that makes sense, but if we turn it into an isobar it would be $ce{^13C(p:7, n:6)}$, which doesn't make sense, because it looks exactly like an isotope of nitrogen $ce{^13N(p:7, n:6)}$.
If the atomic number changes than the element changes as well. So isn't an isobar just an isotope of the following element with a smaller neutron number?
terminology isotope
New contributor
I am a little bit confused about what an isobar is. Its online definition is that it's an element with the same number of neutrons but a different number of protons from an element $ce{X}$.
To me, it doesn't make sense from the get-go, because once you change the number of protons the element changes as well so why exactly is it defined as the same element $ce{X}$ with the same number of neutrons and a different number of protons.
Definition of an isotope: An isotope is an element $ce{X}$ with the same number of protons and a different number of neutrons.
So to the actual question now. Isn't an isobar just an isotope? Here is an example to clarify what I mean.
If we take for example carbon $ce{^12C(p:6, n:6)}$ and turn it into an isotope it will be $ce{^13C(p:6, n:7)}$, and that makes sense, but if we turn it into an isobar it would be $ce{^13C(p:7, n:6)}$, which doesn't make sense, because it looks exactly like an isotope of nitrogen $ce{^13N(p:7, n:6)}$.
If the atomic number changes than the element changes as well. So isn't an isobar just an isotope of the following element with a smaller neutron number?
terminology isotope
terminology isotope
New contributor
New contributor
edited yesterday
Martin - マーチン♦
33.1k9104224
33.1k9104224
New contributor
asked yesterday
Beatrice H.
1017
1017
New contributor
New contributor
2
Related: What are compounds with the same mass called? and What are isodiaphers?
– Loong♦
yesterday
4
To me an isobar is a line on a weather chart connecting points of the same atmospheric pressure.
– Ross Millikan
yesterday
@RossMillikan Me too. Maybe because my eldest brother was a USAF meteorologist, I pay more attention to that kind of isobar. Very confusing for the same word to mean very different things in different branches of science.
– Monty Harder
23 hours ago
@MontyHarder: wiki tells me that old greek βάρος (baros) means weight en.wiktionary.org/wiki/%CE%B2%CE%AC%CF%81%CE%BF%CF%82. So the isobar = same mass/weight seems to be closer to the direct translation of the term than same pressure (which of course is the weight of the atmosphere per area) And btw. in the chart of nuclides you do have isobaric lines as well.
– cbeleites
8 hours ago
add a comment |
2
Related: What are compounds with the same mass called? and What are isodiaphers?
– Loong♦
yesterday
4
To me an isobar is a line on a weather chart connecting points of the same atmospheric pressure.
– Ross Millikan
yesterday
@RossMillikan Me too. Maybe because my eldest brother was a USAF meteorologist, I pay more attention to that kind of isobar. Very confusing for the same word to mean very different things in different branches of science.
– Monty Harder
23 hours ago
@MontyHarder: wiki tells me that old greek βάρος (baros) means weight en.wiktionary.org/wiki/%CE%B2%CE%AC%CF%81%CE%BF%CF%82. So the isobar = same mass/weight seems to be closer to the direct translation of the term than same pressure (which of course is the weight of the atmosphere per area) And btw. in the chart of nuclides you do have isobaric lines as well.
– cbeleites
8 hours ago
2
2
Related: What are compounds with the same mass called? and What are isodiaphers?
– Loong♦
yesterday
Related: What are compounds with the same mass called? and What are isodiaphers?
– Loong♦
yesterday
4
4
To me an isobar is a line on a weather chart connecting points of the same atmospheric pressure.
– Ross Millikan
yesterday
To me an isobar is a line on a weather chart connecting points of the same atmospheric pressure.
– Ross Millikan
yesterday
@RossMillikan Me too. Maybe because my eldest brother was a USAF meteorologist, I pay more attention to that kind of isobar. Very confusing for the same word to mean very different things in different branches of science.
– Monty Harder
23 hours ago
@RossMillikan Me too. Maybe because my eldest brother was a USAF meteorologist, I pay more attention to that kind of isobar. Very confusing for the same word to mean very different things in different branches of science.
– Monty Harder
23 hours ago
@MontyHarder: wiki tells me that old greek βάρος (baros) means weight en.wiktionary.org/wiki/%CE%B2%CE%AC%CF%81%CE%BF%CF%82. So the isobar = same mass/weight seems to be closer to the direct translation of the term than same pressure (which of course is the weight of the atmosphere per area) And btw. in the chart of nuclides you do have isobaric lines as well.
– cbeleites
8 hours ago
@MontyHarder: wiki tells me that old greek βάρος (baros) means weight en.wiktionary.org/wiki/%CE%B2%CE%AC%CF%81%CE%BF%CF%82. So the isobar = same mass/weight seems to be closer to the direct translation of the term than same pressure (which of course is the weight of the atmosphere per area) And btw. in the chart of nuclides you do have isobaric lines as well.
– cbeleites
8 hours ago
add a comment |
3 Answers
3
active
oldest
votes
up vote
31
down vote
accepted
Not quite, an isotope has same number of protons ($ A- N = Z = mathrm{constant}$), but a different number of neutrons ($mathrm N$ varies; e.g. $ce{^3_color{red}{1}H}$ and $ce{^2_color{red}{1}H}$, or $ce{^295_color{red}{92}U}$ and $ce{^238_color{red}{92}U}$ are isotopes).
An isobar has a fixed number of total nucleons ($Z + N = A = mathrm{constant}$; e.g. $ce{^color{red}{40}_19K}$ and $ce{^color{red}{40}_20Ca}$, or $ce{^color{red}{3}_2He}$ and $ce{^color{red}{3}_1H}$ are isobars). Not nearly as mainstream as isotopes, but isobars are important to consider when doing mass spectroscopy.
Extra fact: For nuclei of the same number of neutrons ($A - Z = N = mathrm{constant}$), the term is isotones.
8
Well, I learned something new today.
– Todd Minehardt
yesterday
5
@ToddMinehardt learning something new is the only reason I come back.
– A.K.
yesterday
1
Welp, I guess I was wrong!
– jonsca♦
yesterday
1
@jonsca first thing I thought of was surge protectors.
– A.K.
yesterday
1
People who don't know as much as A.K. often use "isotope" to mean "you know, like, carbon-14 or something", i.e. all nuclei with a given pair of values for $Z,,N$. In case anyone's curious, the term you want for that is nuclide.
– J.G.
yesterday
add a comment |
up vote
11
down vote
I believe the definition you found may have been a little bit misleading. Here is another definition of isobar I found: each of two or more isotopes of different elements, with the same atomic weight. An isobar is referring to completely different elements. The prefix iso- means only one component must be the same between the different elements, and in the case of an isobar: mass.
I saw in your question the example that an isobar of carbon-13 would look like so $ce{^13C(p:7, n:6)}$; however, this is not proper notation, as an isobar cannot be of the same element. Once the number of protons changes, your element is no longer the same.
Isobars are simply two different elements with the same mass while isotopes are two of the same elements with different masses.
@Jon That is the same example as in the question and source of the whole confusion.
– Martin - マーチン♦
yesterday
add a comment |
up vote
7
down vote
Isobar is of more interest to physics than chemistry.
As others have explained, your definition is confusing. The one here may be clearer: isobar (Wikipedia).
In chemistry, the number of protons is most significant since it determines the number of electrons and hence the chemical behaviour. The number of neutrons is relatively unimportant: variants may be useful for labeling and may have slightly different behaviour (most noticeable for $ce{^1H}$ and $ce{^2H}$). So, isotope is used fairly frequently to discuss these variants of the elements. Isobars may have very different chemical behaviour and are unlikely to be an interesting grouping.
In nuclear physics, the number of neutrons and protons have a similar significance hence the term nuclide (Wikipedia) for atoms with a specific number of protons and neutrons is useful. Isobars have a closer connection with each other than isotopes since isobars can interconvert via beta processes relatively easily. It is rare for an atom to decay into an isotope. For example, $ce{^{14}C}$ decays into $ce{^{14}N}$ rather than $ce{^{13}C}$ .
Isobars will be relevant in some specific situations in chemistry such mass spectroscopy. So, it is still useful to understand the concept.
Thank you for the explanation. Yes, your right, this question is more of a physical topic than chemical topic, but since the first time I heard about it was in chemistry I mixed it up. Thank you for pointing that out. I will look into the right stackexchange next time.
– Beatrice H.
yesterday
1
@BeatriceHurbean I'm sure isobar is discussed more in physics than chemistry, but as Loong's related post suggestion shows isobars are important to consider in mass spectroscopy, so very much a chemistry topic too.
– A.K.
yesterday
1
@A.K. Thanks - a good point.
– badjohn
yesterday
add a comment |
3 Answers
3
active
oldest
votes
3 Answers
3
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
up vote
31
down vote
accepted
Not quite, an isotope has same number of protons ($ A- N = Z = mathrm{constant}$), but a different number of neutrons ($mathrm N$ varies; e.g. $ce{^3_color{red}{1}H}$ and $ce{^2_color{red}{1}H}$, or $ce{^295_color{red}{92}U}$ and $ce{^238_color{red}{92}U}$ are isotopes).
An isobar has a fixed number of total nucleons ($Z + N = A = mathrm{constant}$; e.g. $ce{^color{red}{40}_19K}$ and $ce{^color{red}{40}_20Ca}$, or $ce{^color{red}{3}_2He}$ and $ce{^color{red}{3}_1H}$ are isobars). Not nearly as mainstream as isotopes, but isobars are important to consider when doing mass spectroscopy.
Extra fact: For nuclei of the same number of neutrons ($A - Z = N = mathrm{constant}$), the term is isotones.
8
Well, I learned something new today.
– Todd Minehardt
yesterday
5
@ToddMinehardt learning something new is the only reason I come back.
– A.K.
yesterday
1
Welp, I guess I was wrong!
– jonsca♦
yesterday
1
@jonsca first thing I thought of was surge protectors.
– A.K.
yesterday
1
People who don't know as much as A.K. often use "isotope" to mean "you know, like, carbon-14 or something", i.e. all nuclei with a given pair of values for $Z,,N$. In case anyone's curious, the term you want for that is nuclide.
– J.G.
yesterday
add a comment |
up vote
31
down vote
accepted
Not quite, an isotope has same number of protons ($ A- N = Z = mathrm{constant}$), but a different number of neutrons ($mathrm N$ varies; e.g. $ce{^3_color{red}{1}H}$ and $ce{^2_color{red}{1}H}$, or $ce{^295_color{red}{92}U}$ and $ce{^238_color{red}{92}U}$ are isotopes).
An isobar has a fixed number of total nucleons ($Z + N = A = mathrm{constant}$; e.g. $ce{^color{red}{40}_19K}$ and $ce{^color{red}{40}_20Ca}$, or $ce{^color{red}{3}_2He}$ and $ce{^color{red}{3}_1H}$ are isobars). Not nearly as mainstream as isotopes, but isobars are important to consider when doing mass spectroscopy.
Extra fact: For nuclei of the same number of neutrons ($A - Z = N = mathrm{constant}$), the term is isotones.
8
Well, I learned something new today.
– Todd Minehardt
yesterday
5
@ToddMinehardt learning something new is the only reason I come back.
– A.K.
yesterday
1
Welp, I guess I was wrong!
– jonsca♦
yesterday
1
@jonsca first thing I thought of was surge protectors.
– A.K.
yesterday
1
People who don't know as much as A.K. often use "isotope" to mean "you know, like, carbon-14 or something", i.e. all nuclei with a given pair of values for $Z,,N$. In case anyone's curious, the term you want for that is nuclide.
– J.G.
yesterday
add a comment |
up vote
31
down vote
accepted
up vote
31
down vote
accepted
Not quite, an isotope has same number of protons ($ A- N = Z = mathrm{constant}$), but a different number of neutrons ($mathrm N$ varies; e.g. $ce{^3_color{red}{1}H}$ and $ce{^2_color{red}{1}H}$, or $ce{^295_color{red}{92}U}$ and $ce{^238_color{red}{92}U}$ are isotopes).
An isobar has a fixed number of total nucleons ($Z + N = A = mathrm{constant}$; e.g. $ce{^color{red}{40}_19K}$ and $ce{^color{red}{40}_20Ca}$, or $ce{^color{red}{3}_2He}$ and $ce{^color{red}{3}_1H}$ are isobars). Not nearly as mainstream as isotopes, but isobars are important to consider when doing mass spectroscopy.
Extra fact: For nuclei of the same number of neutrons ($A - Z = N = mathrm{constant}$), the term is isotones.
Not quite, an isotope has same number of protons ($ A- N = Z = mathrm{constant}$), but a different number of neutrons ($mathrm N$ varies; e.g. $ce{^3_color{red}{1}H}$ and $ce{^2_color{red}{1}H}$, or $ce{^295_color{red}{92}U}$ and $ce{^238_color{red}{92}U}$ are isotopes).
An isobar has a fixed number of total nucleons ($Z + N = A = mathrm{constant}$; e.g. $ce{^color{red}{40}_19K}$ and $ce{^color{red}{40}_20Ca}$, or $ce{^color{red}{3}_2He}$ and $ce{^color{red}{3}_1H}$ are isobars). Not nearly as mainstream as isotopes, but isobars are important to consider when doing mass spectroscopy.
Extra fact: For nuclei of the same number of neutrons ($A - Z = N = mathrm{constant}$), the term is isotones.
edited 19 hours ago
answered yesterday
A.K.
8,10441861
8,10441861
8
Well, I learned something new today.
– Todd Minehardt
yesterday
5
@ToddMinehardt learning something new is the only reason I come back.
– A.K.
yesterday
1
Welp, I guess I was wrong!
– jonsca♦
yesterday
1
@jonsca first thing I thought of was surge protectors.
– A.K.
yesterday
1
People who don't know as much as A.K. often use "isotope" to mean "you know, like, carbon-14 or something", i.e. all nuclei with a given pair of values for $Z,,N$. In case anyone's curious, the term you want for that is nuclide.
– J.G.
yesterday
add a comment |
8
Well, I learned something new today.
– Todd Minehardt
yesterday
5
@ToddMinehardt learning something new is the only reason I come back.
– A.K.
yesterday
1
Welp, I guess I was wrong!
– jonsca♦
yesterday
1
@jonsca first thing I thought of was surge protectors.
– A.K.
yesterday
1
People who don't know as much as A.K. often use "isotope" to mean "you know, like, carbon-14 or something", i.e. all nuclei with a given pair of values for $Z,,N$. In case anyone's curious, the term you want for that is nuclide.
– J.G.
yesterday
8
8
Well, I learned something new today.
– Todd Minehardt
yesterday
Well, I learned something new today.
– Todd Minehardt
yesterday
5
5
@ToddMinehardt learning something new is the only reason I come back.
– A.K.
yesterday
@ToddMinehardt learning something new is the only reason I come back.
– A.K.
yesterday
1
1
Welp, I guess I was wrong!
– jonsca♦
yesterday
Welp, I guess I was wrong!
– jonsca♦
yesterday
1
1
@jonsca first thing I thought of was surge protectors.
– A.K.
yesterday
@jonsca first thing I thought of was surge protectors.
– A.K.
yesterday
1
1
People who don't know as much as A.K. often use "isotope" to mean "you know, like, carbon-14 or something", i.e. all nuclei with a given pair of values for $Z,,N$. In case anyone's curious, the term you want for that is nuclide.
– J.G.
yesterday
People who don't know as much as A.K. often use "isotope" to mean "you know, like, carbon-14 or something", i.e. all nuclei with a given pair of values for $Z,,N$. In case anyone's curious, the term you want for that is nuclide.
– J.G.
yesterday
add a comment |
up vote
11
down vote
I believe the definition you found may have been a little bit misleading. Here is another definition of isobar I found: each of two or more isotopes of different elements, with the same atomic weight. An isobar is referring to completely different elements. The prefix iso- means only one component must be the same between the different elements, and in the case of an isobar: mass.
I saw in your question the example that an isobar of carbon-13 would look like so $ce{^13C(p:7, n:6)}$; however, this is not proper notation, as an isobar cannot be of the same element. Once the number of protons changes, your element is no longer the same.
Isobars are simply two different elements with the same mass while isotopes are two of the same elements with different masses.
@Jon That is the same example as in the question and source of the whole confusion.
– Martin - マーチン♦
yesterday
add a comment |
up vote
11
down vote
I believe the definition you found may have been a little bit misleading. Here is another definition of isobar I found: each of two or more isotopes of different elements, with the same atomic weight. An isobar is referring to completely different elements. The prefix iso- means only one component must be the same between the different elements, and in the case of an isobar: mass.
I saw in your question the example that an isobar of carbon-13 would look like so $ce{^13C(p:7, n:6)}$; however, this is not proper notation, as an isobar cannot be of the same element. Once the number of protons changes, your element is no longer the same.
Isobars are simply two different elements with the same mass while isotopes are two of the same elements with different masses.
@Jon That is the same example as in the question and source of the whole confusion.
– Martin - マーチン♦
yesterday
add a comment |
up vote
11
down vote
up vote
11
down vote
I believe the definition you found may have been a little bit misleading. Here is another definition of isobar I found: each of two or more isotopes of different elements, with the same atomic weight. An isobar is referring to completely different elements. The prefix iso- means only one component must be the same between the different elements, and in the case of an isobar: mass.
I saw in your question the example that an isobar of carbon-13 would look like so $ce{^13C(p:7, n:6)}$; however, this is not proper notation, as an isobar cannot be of the same element. Once the number of protons changes, your element is no longer the same.
Isobars are simply two different elements with the same mass while isotopes are two of the same elements with different masses.
I believe the definition you found may have been a little bit misleading. Here is another definition of isobar I found: each of two or more isotopes of different elements, with the same atomic weight. An isobar is referring to completely different elements. The prefix iso- means only one component must be the same between the different elements, and in the case of an isobar: mass.
I saw in your question the example that an isobar of carbon-13 would look like so $ce{^13C(p:7, n:6)}$; however, this is not proper notation, as an isobar cannot be of the same element. Once the number of protons changes, your element is no longer the same.
Isobars are simply two different elements with the same mass while isotopes are two of the same elements with different masses.
edited yesterday
Martin - マーチン♦
33.1k9104224
33.1k9104224
answered yesterday
ELI JONES
1264
1264
@Jon That is the same example as in the question and source of the whole confusion.
– Martin - マーチン♦
yesterday
add a comment |
@Jon That is the same example as in the question and source of the whole confusion.
– Martin - マーチン♦
yesterday
@Jon That is the same example as in the question and source of the whole confusion.
– Martin - マーチン♦
yesterday
@Jon That is the same example as in the question and source of the whole confusion.
– Martin - マーチン♦
yesterday
add a comment |
up vote
7
down vote
Isobar is of more interest to physics than chemistry.
As others have explained, your definition is confusing. The one here may be clearer: isobar (Wikipedia).
In chemistry, the number of protons is most significant since it determines the number of electrons and hence the chemical behaviour. The number of neutrons is relatively unimportant: variants may be useful for labeling and may have slightly different behaviour (most noticeable for $ce{^1H}$ and $ce{^2H}$). So, isotope is used fairly frequently to discuss these variants of the elements. Isobars may have very different chemical behaviour and are unlikely to be an interesting grouping.
In nuclear physics, the number of neutrons and protons have a similar significance hence the term nuclide (Wikipedia) for atoms with a specific number of protons and neutrons is useful. Isobars have a closer connection with each other than isotopes since isobars can interconvert via beta processes relatively easily. It is rare for an atom to decay into an isotope. For example, $ce{^{14}C}$ decays into $ce{^{14}N}$ rather than $ce{^{13}C}$ .
Isobars will be relevant in some specific situations in chemistry such mass spectroscopy. So, it is still useful to understand the concept.
Thank you for the explanation. Yes, your right, this question is more of a physical topic than chemical topic, but since the first time I heard about it was in chemistry I mixed it up. Thank you for pointing that out. I will look into the right stackexchange next time.
– Beatrice H.
yesterday
1
@BeatriceHurbean I'm sure isobar is discussed more in physics than chemistry, but as Loong's related post suggestion shows isobars are important to consider in mass spectroscopy, so very much a chemistry topic too.
– A.K.
yesterday
1
@A.K. Thanks - a good point.
– badjohn
yesterday
add a comment |
up vote
7
down vote
Isobar is of more interest to physics than chemistry.
As others have explained, your definition is confusing. The one here may be clearer: isobar (Wikipedia).
In chemistry, the number of protons is most significant since it determines the number of electrons and hence the chemical behaviour. The number of neutrons is relatively unimportant: variants may be useful for labeling and may have slightly different behaviour (most noticeable for $ce{^1H}$ and $ce{^2H}$). So, isotope is used fairly frequently to discuss these variants of the elements. Isobars may have very different chemical behaviour and are unlikely to be an interesting grouping.
In nuclear physics, the number of neutrons and protons have a similar significance hence the term nuclide (Wikipedia) for atoms with a specific number of protons and neutrons is useful. Isobars have a closer connection with each other than isotopes since isobars can interconvert via beta processes relatively easily. It is rare for an atom to decay into an isotope. For example, $ce{^{14}C}$ decays into $ce{^{14}N}$ rather than $ce{^{13}C}$ .
Isobars will be relevant in some specific situations in chemistry such mass spectroscopy. So, it is still useful to understand the concept.
Thank you for the explanation. Yes, your right, this question is more of a physical topic than chemical topic, but since the first time I heard about it was in chemistry I mixed it up. Thank you for pointing that out. I will look into the right stackexchange next time.
– Beatrice H.
yesterday
1
@BeatriceHurbean I'm sure isobar is discussed more in physics than chemistry, but as Loong's related post suggestion shows isobars are important to consider in mass spectroscopy, so very much a chemistry topic too.
– A.K.
yesterday
1
@A.K. Thanks - a good point.
– badjohn
yesterday
add a comment |
up vote
7
down vote
up vote
7
down vote
Isobar is of more interest to physics than chemistry.
As others have explained, your definition is confusing. The one here may be clearer: isobar (Wikipedia).
In chemistry, the number of protons is most significant since it determines the number of electrons and hence the chemical behaviour. The number of neutrons is relatively unimportant: variants may be useful for labeling and may have slightly different behaviour (most noticeable for $ce{^1H}$ and $ce{^2H}$). So, isotope is used fairly frequently to discuss these variants of the elements. Isobars may have very different chemical behaviour and are unlikely to be an interesting grouping.
In nuclear physics, the number of neutrons and protons have a similar significance hence the term nuclide (Wikipedia) for atoms with a specific number of protons and neutrons is useful. Isobars have a closer connection with each other than isotopes since isobars can interconvert via beta processes relatively easily. It is rare for an atom to decay into an isotope. For example, $ce{^{14}C}$ decays into $ce{^{14}N}$ rather than $ce{^{13}C}$ .
Isobars will be relevant in some specific situations in chemistry such mass spectroscopy. So, it is still useful to understand the concept.
Isobar is of more interest to physics than chemistry.
As others have explained, your definition is confusing. The one here may be clearer: isobar (Wikipedia).
In chemistry, the number of protons is most significant since it determines the number of electrons and hence the chemical behaviour. The number of neutrons is relatively unimportant: variants may be useful for labeling and may have slightly different behaviour (most noticeable for $ce{^1H}$ and $ce{^2H}$). So, isotope is used fairly frequently to discuss these variants of the elements. Isobars may have very different chemical behaviour and are unlikely to be an interesting grouping.
In nuclear physics, the number of neutrons and protons have a similar significance hence the term nuclide (Wikipedia) for atoms with a specific number of protons and neutrons is useful. Isobars have a closer connection with each other than isotopes since isobars can interconvert via beta processes relatively easily. It is rare for an atom to decay into an isotope. For example, $ce{^{14}C}$ decays into $ce{^{14}N}$ rather than $ce{^{13}C}$ .
Isobars will be relevant in some specific situations in chemistry such mass spectroscopy. So, it is still useful to understand the concept.
edited yesterday
answered yesterday
badjohn
451111
451111
Thank you for the explanation. Yes, your right, this question is more of a physical topic than chemical topic, but since the first time I heard about it was in chemistry I mixed it up. Thank you for pointing that out. I will look into the right stackexchange next time.
– Beatrice H.
yesterday
1
@BeatriceHurbean I'm sure isobar is discussed more in physics than chemistry, but as Loong's related post suggestion shows isobars are important to consider in mass spectroscopy, so very much a chemistry topic too.
– A.K.
yesterday
1
@A.K. Thanks - a good point.
– badjohn
yesterday
add a comment |
Thank you for the explanation. Yes, your right, this question is more of a physical topic than chemical topic, but since the first time I heard about it was in chemistry I mixed it up. Thank you for pointing that out. I will look into the right stackexchange next time.
– Beatrice H.
yesterday
1
@BeatriceHurbean I'm sure isobar is discussed more in physics than chemistry, but as Loong's related post suggestion shows isobars are important to consider in mass spectroscopy, so very much a chemistry topic too.
– A.K.
yesterday
1
@A.K. Thanks - a good point.
– badjohn
yesterday
Thank you for the explanation. Yes, your right, this question is more of a physical topic than chemical topic, but since the first time I heard about it was in chemistry I mixed it up. Thank you for pointing that out. I will look into the right stackexchange next time.
– Beatrice H.
yesterday
Thank you for the explanation. Yes, your right, this question is more of a physical topic than chemical topic, but since the first time I heard about it was in chemistry I mixed it up. Thank you for pointing that out. I will look into the right stackexchange next time.
– Beatrice H.
yesterday
1
1
@BeatriceHurbean I'm sure isobar is discussed more in physics than chemistry, but as Loong's related post suggestion shows isobars are important to consider in mass spectroscopy, so very much a chemistry topic too.
– A.K.
yesterday
@BeatriceHurbean I'm sure isobar is discussed more in physics than chemistry, but as Loong's related post suggestion shows isobars are important to consider in mass spectroscopy, so very much a chemistry topic too.
– A.K.
yesterday
1
1
@A.K. Thanks - a good point.
– badjohn
yesterday
@A.K. Thanks - a good point.
– badjohn
yesterday
add a comment |
Beatrice H. is a new contributor. Be nice, and check out our Code of Conduct.
Beatrice H. is a new contributor. Be nice, and check out our Code of Conduct.
Beatrice H. is a new contributor. Be nice, and check out our Code of Conduct.
Beatrice H. is a new contributor. Be nice, and check out our Code of Conduct.
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function () {
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
});
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
StackExchange.ready(
function () {
StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2fchemistry.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f104382%2fis-an-isobar-the-same-as-an-isotope%23new-answer', 'question_page');
}
);
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function () {
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
});
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function () {
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
});
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function () {
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
});
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
2
Related: What are compounds with the same mass called? and What are isodiaphers?
– Loong♦
yesterday
4
To me an isobar is a line on a weather chart connecting points of the same atmospheric pressure.
– Ross Millikan
yesterday
@RossMillikan Me too. Maybe because my eldest brother was a USAF meteorologist, I pay more attention to that kind of isobar. Very confusing for the same word to mean very different things in different branches of science.
– Monty Harder
23 hours ago
@MontyHarder: wiki tells me that old greek βάρος (baros) means weight en.wiktionary.org/wiki/%CE%B2%CE%AC%CF%81%CE%BF%CF%82. So the isobar = same mass/weight seems to be closer to the direct translation of the term than same pressure (which of course is the weight of the atmosphere per area) And btw. in the chart of nuclides you do have isobaric lines as well.
– cbeleites
8 hours ago