Where does the emperor sit and why the earplugs?











up vote
2
down vote

favorite












The Emperor is annoyed that the crowd routinely chant out of step at the Empire's largest circular amphitheatre. For example, they are supposed to shout phrases in unison such as "Hail to the Emperor, he is great!" and yet they always sound like a rabble.



All powerful though he may be, he realises he can't punish the whole crowd at every event. Bread and circuses and all that.



Nevertheless he decides that just for once on his next birthday his Court Musician must arrange an event where he trains a crowd of people (the chorus) to occupy the front few rows of the arena's seats and chant a spoken birthday ode to him in perfect time.



Question



How does the Court Musician keep everyone in time?



Why does he equip everyone in the chorus with earplugs?



Where is the only place for the Emperor's throne and why?



EDITED to tidy up and make clearer. Apologies if I have changed anything too much.










share|improve this question
























  • might as well add mathematics/ geometry tag?
    – Omega Krypton
    1 hour ago












  • @ Omega Krypton - I think maybe I'll add physics and geometry.
    – chasly from UK
    43 mins ago















up vote
2
down vote

favorite












The Emperor is annoyed that the crowd routinely chant out of step at the Empire's largest circular amphitheatre. For example, they are supposed to shout phrases in unison such as "Hail to the Emperor, he is great!" and yet they always sound like a rabble.



All powerful though he may be, he realises he can't punish the whole crowd at every event. Bread and circuses and all that.



Nevertheless he decides that just for once on his next birthday his Court Musician must arrange an event where he trains a crowd of people (the chorus) to occupy the front few rows of the arena's seats and chant a spoken birthday ode to him in perfect time.



Question



How does the Court Musician keep everyone in time?



Why does he equip everyone in the chorus with earplugs?



Where is the only place for the Emperor's throne and why?



EDITED to tidy up and make clearer. Apologies if I have changed anything too much.










share|improve this question
























  • might as well add mathematics/ geometry tag?
    – Omega Krypton
    1 hour ago












  • @ Omega Krypton - I think maybe I'll add physics and geometry.
    – chasly from UK
    43 mins ago













up vote
2
down vote

favorite









up vote
2
down vote

favorite











The Emperor is annoyed that the crowd routinely chant out of step at the Empire's largest circular amphitheatre. For example, they are supposed to shout phrases in unison such as "Hail to the Emperor, he is great!" and yet they always sound like a rabble.



All powerful though he may be, he realises he can't punish the whole crowd at every event. Bread and circuses and all that.



Nevertheless he decides that just for once on his next birthday his Court Musician must arrange an event where he trains a crowd of people (the chorus) to occupy the front few rows of the arena's seats and chant a spoken birthday ode to him in perfect time.



Question



How does the Court Musician keep everyone in time?



Why does he equip everyone in the chorus with earplugs?



Where is the only place for the Emperor's throne and why?



EDITED to tidy up and make clearer. Apologies if I have changed anything too much.










share|improve this question















The Emperor is annoyed that the crowd routinely chant out of step at the Empire's largest circular amphitheatre. For example, they are supposed to shout phrases in unison such as "Hail to the Emperor, he is great!" and yet they always sound like a rabble.



All powerful though he may be, he realises he can't punish the whole crowd at every event. Bread and circuses and all that.



Nevertheless he decides that just for once on his next birthday his Court Musician must arrange an event where he trains a crowd of people (the chorus) to occupy the front few rows of the arena's seats and chant a spoken birthday ode to him in perfect time.



Question



How does the Court Musician keep everyone in time?



Why does he equip everyone in the chorus with earplugs?



Where is the only place for the Emperor's throne and why?



EDITED to tidy up and make clearer. Apologies if I have changed anything too much.







geometry music science physics






share|improve this question















share|improve this question













share|improve this question




share|improve this question








edited 42 mins ago

























asked 1 hour ago









chasly from UK

2,7651145




2,7651145












  • might as well add mathematics/ geometry tag?
    – Omega Krypton
    1 hour ago












  • @ Omega Krypton - I think maybe I'll add physics and geometry.
    – chasly from UK
    43 mins ago


















  • might as well add mathematics/ geometry tag?
    – Omega Krypton
    1 hour ago












  • @ Omega Krypton - I think maybe I'll add physics and geometry.
    – chasly from UK
    43 mins ago
















might as well add mathematics/ geometry tag?
– Omega Krypton
1 hour ago






might as well add mathematics/ geometry tag?
– Omega Krypton
1 hour ago














@ Omega Krypton - I think maybe I'll add physics and geometry.
– chasly from UK
43 mins ago




@ Omega Krypton - I think maybe I'll add physics and geometry.
– chasly from UK
43 mins ago










4 Answers
4






active

oldest

votes

















up vote
3
down vote



accepted










How does the Court Musician keep everyone in time?




All need to be able to see the Court Musician who will act as a choral conductor




Why does he equip everyone in the chorus with earplugs?




So they don't go off the rhythm, misled by the other singers. Each one of them is surrounded by singers which are at ever increasing distance from them. They here a lot of people singing the same theme but slightly delayed. That's why you can see a lot of singers in pop groups covering one of their ears. This helps them hear their own voice so they don't go off tune and the conductor shows them the tempo.




Where is the only place for the Emperor's throne and why?




All singers must be equidistant so ideally the throne will be in the centre of a circle of singers. This way the sound will travel the same time the Emperor and he will hear them all singing in unison.







share|improve this answer























  • This is all correct. Can you explain why the problem you discuss in 2, might happen? (In fact will definitely tend to happen)
    – chasly from UK
    1 hour ago












  • @rhsquared refer to my answer for the last bit
    – Omega Krypton
    1 hour ago










  • I'm sure you have this. I suppose I'm asking: If you take the Emperor out of the equation and they stand as you suggest then why would they inevitably cause problems for each other?
    – chasly from UK
    53 mins ago


















up vote
1
down vote













Partial Answer:



Why the earplugs?




To minimize the error time when the one's voice reaches another's ear. Another type of signal, perhaps visual, is needed.







share|improve this answer























  • What you say is correct.
    – chasly from UK
    1 hour ago


















up vote
1
down vote













I'll post this as an answer to my own question. Please note that @rhsquared got the whole thing right. I'm simply adding a commentary.




It is actually impossible for a full arena of people to sound to any listener in the arena as though the crowd are singing or chanting perfectly in time. Even if they are conducted by someone standing in the middle, the sound delay is always there. As @S.M. points out, even the conductor will be affected by the delay between the back seats and the front ones.







share|improve this answer




























    up vote
    1
    down vote













    Might be a bit of a weak answer, but




    He makes them wear earplugs so that if someone makes a mistake the others won't follow, and even if there aren't any mistakes, the voice of the person next to you will come with a different delay than that of the person standing on the opposite side of the circle; puts the crowd in a circle and sits the emperor in the middle it so he won't hear any delay from the people in the back and it sounds like a "surround" sound instead, all at the same time. About keeping them on time, I don't know, guess the court musician trained them well and we can rely on the quality of his work? Besides since they're all wearing earplugs he can just visually signal them for the tempo.







    share|improve this answer























    • You're partially there. The 'science' part of the question needs to be a little more explicit.
      – chasly from UK
      1 hour ago










    • P.S. I've just realised from your answer that I missed one of the conditions out. I've added it now. Apologies. I should have thought everything through more carefully before posting.
      – chasly from UK
      1 hour ago












    • Well, I've already given the only position he can be in, which is in the center of a circle formed by the crowd, so all the sound is coming from equally distant places.
      – S. M.
      58 mins ago










    • I agree. But the reason for the earplugs is not because someone might make a mistake. Let's suppose they have all memorised everything perfectly and each practised the timing perfectly at home to a metronome.
      – chasly from UK
      26 mins ago








    • 1




      That's why I added the echo, because even if no mistakes were made there'd still be a difference in sound from the person standing next to you in the circle and the person on the opposite side of it, but I wasn't clear enough on it, I suppose. I'll edit my answer even though rhsquared's has already been accepted. Not sure "echo" would even be a correct term at all for what I meant, but it was the first thing that came to mind, my bad there.
      – S. M.
      24 mins ago













    Your Answer





    StackExchange.ifUsing("editor", function () {
    return StackExchange.using("mathjaxEditing", function () {
    StackExchange.MarkdownEditor.creationCallbacks.add(function (editor, postfix) {
    StackExchange.mathjaxEditing.prepareWmdForMathJax(editor, postfix, [["$", "$"], ["\\(","\\)"]]);
    });
    });
    }, "mathjax-editing");

    StackExchange.ready(function() {
    var channelOptions = {
    tags: "".split(" "),
    id: "559"
    };
    initTagRenderer("".split(" "), "".split(" "), channelOptions);

    StackExchange.using("externalEditor", function() {
    // Have to fire editor after snippets, if snippets enabled
    if (StackExchange.settings.snippets.snippetsEnabled) {
    StackExchange.using("snippets", function() {
    createEditor();
    });
    }
    else {
    createEditor();
    }
    });

    function createEditor() {
    StackExchange.prepareEditor({
    heartbeatType: 'answer',
    convertImagesToLinks: false,
    noModals: true,
    showLowRepImageUploadWarning: true,
    reputationToPostImages: null,
    bindNavPrevention: true,
    postfix: "",
    imageUploader: {
    brandingHtml: "Powered by u003ca class="icon-imgur-white" href="https://imgur.com/"u003eu003c/au003e",
    contentPolicyHtml: "User contributions licensed under u003ca href="https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/3.0/"u003ecc by-sa 3.0 with attribution requiredu003c/au003e u003ca href="https://stackoverflow.com/legal/content-policy"u003e(content policy)u003c/au003e",
    allowUrls: true
    },
    noCode: true, onDemand: true,
    discardSelector: ".discard-answer"
    ,immediatelyShowMarkdownHelp:true
    });


    }
    });














    draft saved

    draft discarded


















    StackExchange.ready(
    function () {
    StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2fpuzzling.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f76438%2fwhere-does-the-emperor-sit-and-why-the-earplugs%23new-answer', 'question_page');
    }
    );

    Post as a guest















    Required, but never shown

























    4 Answers
    4






    active

    oldest

    votes








    4 Answers
    4






    active

    oldest

    votes









    active

    oldest

    votes






    active

    oldest

    votes








    up vote
    3
    down vote



    accepted










    How does the Court Musician keep everyone in time?




    All need to be able to see the Court Musician who will act as a choral conductor




    Why does he equip everyone in the chorus with earplugs?




    So they don't go off the rhythm, misled by the other singers. Each one of them is surrounded by singers which are at ever increasing distance from them. They here a lot of people singing the same theme but slightly delayed. That's why you can see a lot of singers in pop groups covering one of their ears. This helps them hear their own voice so they don't go off tune and the conductor shows them the tempo.




    Where is the only place for the Emperor's throne and why?




    All singers must be equidistant so ideally the throne will be in the centre of a circle of singers. This way the sound will travel the same time the Emperor and he will hear them all singing in unison.







    share|improve this answer























    • This is all correct. Can you explain why the problem you discuss in 2, might happen? (In fact will definitely tend to happen)
      – chasly from UK
      1 hour ago












    • @rhsquared refer to my answer for the last bit
      – Omega Krypton
      1 hour ago










    • I'm sure you have this. I suppose I'm asking: If you take the Emperor out of the equation and they stand as you suggest then why would they inevitably cause problems for each other?
      – chasly from UK
      53 mins ago















    up vote
    3
    down vote



    accepted










    How does the Court Musician keep everyone in time?




    All need to be able to see the Court Musician who will act as a choral conductor




    Why does he equip everyone in the chorus with earplugs?




    So they don't go off the rhythm, misled by the other singers. Each one of them is surrounded by singers which are at ever increasing distance from them. They here a lot of people singing the same theme but slightly delayed. That's why you can see a lot of singers in pop groups covering one of their ears. This helps them hear their own voice so they don't go off tune and the conductor shows them the tempo.




    Where is the only place for the Emperor's throne and why?




    All singers must be equidistant so ideally the throne will be in the centre of a circle of singers. This way the sound will travel the same time the Emperor and he will hear them all singing in unison.







    share|improve this answer























    • This is all correct. Can you explain why the problem you discuss in 2, might happen? (In fact will definitely tend to happen)
      – chasly from UK
      1 hour ago












    • @rhsquared refer to my answer for the last bit
      – Omega Krypton
      1 hour ago










    • I'm sure you have this. I suppose I'm asking: If you take the Emperor out of the equation and they stand as you suggest then why would they inevitably cause problems for each other?
      – chasly from UK
      53 mins ago













    up vote
    3
    down vote



    accepted







    up vote
    3
    down vote



    accepted






    How does the Court Musician keep everyone in time?




    All need to be able to see the Court Musician who will act as a choral conductor




    Why does he equip everyone in the chorus with earplugs?




    So they don't go off the rhythm, misled by the other singers. Each one of them is surrounded by singers which are at ever increasing distance from them. They here a lot of people singing the same theme but slightly delayed. That's why you can see a lot of singers in pop groups covering one of their ears. This helps them hear their own voice so they don't go off tune and the conductor shows them the tempo.




    Where is the only place for the Emperor's throne and why?




    All singers must be equidistant so ideally the throne will be in the centre of a circle of singers. This way the sound will travel the same time the Emperor and he will hear them all singing in unison.







    share|improve this answer














    How does the Court Musician keep everyone in time?




    All need to be able to see the Court Musician who will act as a choral conductor




    Why does he equip everyone in the chorus with earplugs?




    So they don't go off the rhythm, misled by the other singers. Each one of them is surrounded by singers which are at ever increasing distance from them. They here a lot of people singing the same theme but slightly delayed. That's why you can see a lot of singers in pop groups covering one of their ears. This helps them hear their own voice so they don't go off tune and the conductor shows them the tempo.




    Where is the only place for the Emperor's throne and why?




    All singers must be equidistant so ideally the throne will be in the centre of a circle of singers. This way the sound will travel the same time the Emperor and he will hear them all singing in unison.








    share|improve this answer














    share|improve this answer



    share|improve this answer








    edited 55 mins ago

























    answered 1 hour ago









    rhsquared

    7,09721642




    7,09721642












    • This is all correct. Can you explain why the problem you discuss in 2, might happen? (In fact will definitely tend to happen)
      – chasly from UK
      1 hour ago












    • @rhsquared refer to my answer for the last bit
      – Omega Krypton
      1 hour ago










    • I'm sure you have this. I suppose I'm asking: If you take the Emperor out of the equation and they stand as you suggest then why would they inevitably cause problems for each other?
      – chasly from UK
      53 mins ago


















    • This is all correct. Can you explain why the problem you discuss in 2, might happen? (In fact will definitely tend to happen)
      – chasly from UK
      1 hour ago












    • @rhsquared refer to my answer for the last bit
      – Omega Krypton
      1 hour ago










    • I'm sure you have this. I suppose I'm asking: If you take the Emperor out of the equation and they stand as you suggest then why would they inevitably cause problems for each other?
      – chasly from UK
      53 mins ago
















    This is all correct. Can you explain why the problem you discuss in 2, might happen? (In fact will definitely tend to happen)
    – chasly from UK
    1 hour ago






    This is all correct. Can you explain why the problem you discuss in 2, might happen? (In fact will definitely tend to happen)
    – chasly from UK
    1 hour ago














    @rhsquared refer to my answer for the last bit
    – Omega Krypton
    1 hour ago




    @rhsquared refer to my answer for the last bit
    – Omega Krypton
    1 hour ago












    I'm sure you have this. I suppose I'm asking: If you take the Emperor out of the equation and they stand as you suggest then why would they inevitably cause problems for each other?
    – chasly from UK
    53 mins ago




    I'm sure you have this. I suppose I'm asking: If you take the Emperor out of the equation and they stand as you suggest then why would they inevitably cause problems for each other?
    – chasly from UK
    53 mins ago










    up vote
    1
    down vote













    Partial Answer:



    Why the earplugs?




    To minimize the error time when the one's voice reaches another's ear. Another type of signal, perhaps visual, is needed.







    share|improve this answer























    • What you say is correct.
      – chasly from UK
      1 hour ago















    up vote
    1
    down vote













    Partial Answer:



    Why the earplugs?




    To minimize the error time when the one's voice reaches another's ear. Another type of signal, perhaps visual, is needed.







    share|improve this answer























    • What you say is correct.
      – chasly from UK
      1 hour ago













    up vote
    1
    down vote










    up vote
    1
    down vote









    Partial Answer:



    Why the earplugs?




    To minimize the error time when the one's voice reaches another's ear. Another type of signal, perhaps visual, is needed.







    share|improve this answer














    Partial Answer:



    Why the earplugs?




    To minimize the error time when the one's voice reaches another's ear. Another type of signal, perhaps visual, is needed.








    share|improve this answer














    share|improve this answer



    share|improve this answer








    edited 55 mins ago

























    answered 1 hour ago









    Omega Krypton

    1,7571218




    1,7571218












    • What you say is correct.
      – chasly from UK
      1 hour ago


















    • What you say is correct.
      – chasly from UK
      1 hour ago
















    What you say is correct.
    – chasly from UK
    1 hour ago




    What you say is correct.
    – chasly from UK
    1 hour ago










    up vote
    1
    down vote













    I'll post this as an answer to my own question. Please note that @rhsquared got the whole thing right. I'm simply adding a commentary.




    It is actually impossible for a full arena of people to sound to any listener in the arena as though the crowd are singing or chanting perfectly in time. Even if they are conducted by someone standing in the middle, the sound delay is always there. As @S.M. points out, even the conductor will be affected by the delay between the back seats and the front ones.







    share|improve this answer

























      up vote
      1
      down vote













      I'll post this as an answer to my own question. Please note that @rhsquared got the whole thing right. I'm simply adding a commentary.




      It is actually impossible for a full arena of people to sound to any listener in the arena as though the crowd are singing or chanting perfectly in time. Even if they are conducted by someone standing in the middle, the sound delay is always there. As @S.M. points out, even the conductor will be affected by the delay between the back seats and the front ones.







      share|improve this answer























        up vote
        1
        down vote










        up vote
        1
        down vote









        I'll post this as an answer to my own question. Please note that @rhsquared got the whole thing right. I'm simply adding a commentary.




        It is actually impossible for a full arena of people to sound to any listener in the arena as though the crowd are singing or chanting perfectly in time. Even if they are conducted by someone standing in the middle, the sound delay is always there. As @S.M. points out, even the conductor will be affected by the delay between the back seats and the front ones.







        share|improve this answer












        I'll post this as an answer to my own question. Please note that @rhsquared got the whole thing right. I'm simply adding a commentary.




        It is actually impossible for a full arena of people to sound to any listener in the arena as though the crowd are singing or chanting perfectly in time. Even if they are conducted by someone standing in the middle, the sound delay is always there. As @S.M. points out, even the conductor will be affected by the delay between the back seats and the front ones.








        share|improve this answer












        share|improve this answer



        share|improve this answer










        answered 30 mins ago









        chasly from UK

        2,7651145




        2,7651145






















            up vote
            1
            down vote













            Might be a bit of a weak answer, but




            He makes them wear earplugs so that if someone makes a mistake the others won't follow, and even if there aren't any mistakes, the voice of the person next to you will come with a different delay than that of the person standing on the opposite side of the circle; puts the crowd in a circle and sits the emperor in the middle it so he won't hear any delay from the people in the back and it sounds like a "surround" sound instead, all at the same time. About keeping them on time, I don't know, guess the court musician trained them well and we can rely on the quality of his work? Besides since they're all wearing earplugs he can just visually signal them for the tempo.







            share|improve this answer























            • You're partially there. The 'science' part of the question needs to be a little more explicit.
              – chasly from UK
              1 hour ago










            • P.S. I've just realised from your answer that I missed one of the conditions out. I've added it now. Apologies. I should have thought everything through more carefully before posting.
              – chasly from UK
              1 hour ago












            • Well, I've already given the only position he can be in, which is in the center of a circle formed by the crowd, so all the sound is coming from equally distant places.
              – S. M.
              58 mins ago










            • I agree. But the reason for the earplugs is not because someone might make a mistake. Let's suppose they have all memorised everything perfectly and each practised the timing perfectly at home to a metronome.
              – chasly from UK
              26 mins ago








            • 1




              That's why I added the echo, because even if no mistakes were made there'd still be a difference in sound from the person standing next to you in the circle and the person on the opposite side of it, but I wasn't clear enough on it, I suppose. I'll edit my answer even though rhsquared's has already been accepted. Not sure "echo" would even be a correct term at all for what I meant, but it was the first thing that came to mind, my bad there.
              – S. M.
              24 mins ago

















            up vote
            1
            down vote













            Might be a bit of a weak answer, but




            He makes them wear earplugs so that if someone makes a mistake the others won't follow, and even if there aren't any mistakes, the voice of the person next to you will come with a different delay than that of the person standing on the opposite side of the circle; puts the crowd in a circle and sits the emperor in the middle it so he won't hear any delay from the people in the back and it sounds like a "surround" sound instead, all at the same time. About keeping them on time, I don't know, guess the court musician trained them well and we can rely on the quality of his work? Besides since they're all wearing earplugs he can just visually signal them for the tempo.







            share|improve this answer























            • You're partially there. The 'science' part of the question needs to be a little more explicit.
              – chasly from UK
              1 hour ago










            • P.S. I've just realised from your answer that I missed one of the conditions out. I've added it now. Apologies. I should have thought everything through more carefully before posting.
              – chasly from UK
              1 hour ago












            • Well, I've already given the only position he can be in, which is in the center of a circle formed by the crowd, so all the sound is coming from equally distant places.
              – S. M.
              58 mins ago










            • I agree. But the reason for the earplugs is not because someone might make a mistake. Let's suppose they have all memorised everything perfectly and each practised the timing perfectly at home to a metronome.
              – chasly from UK
              26 mins ago








            • 1




              That's why I added the echo, because even if no mistakes were made there'd still be a difference in sound from the person standing next to you in the circle and the person on the opposite side of it, but I wasn't clear enough on it, I suppose. I'll edit my answer even though rhsquared's has already been accepted. Not sure "echo" would even be a correct term at all for what I meant, but it was the first thing that came to mind, my bad there.
              – S. M.
              24 mins ago















            up vote
            1
            down vote










            up vote
            1
            down vote









            Might be a bit of a weak answer, but




            He makes them wear earplugs so that if someone makes a mistake the others won't follow, and even if there aren't any mistakes, the voice of the person next to you will come with a different delay than that of the person standing on the opposite side of the circle; puts the crowd in a circle and sits the emperor in the middle it so he won't hear any delay from the people in the back and it sounds like a "surround" sound instead, all at the same time. About keeping them on time, I don't know, guess the court musician trained them well and we can rely on the quality of his work? Besides since they're all wearing earplugs he can just visually signal them for the tempo.







            share|improve this answer














            Might be a bit of a weak answer, but




            He makes them wear earplugs so that if someone makes a mistake the others won't follow, and even if there aren't any mistakes, the voice of the person next to you will come with a different delay than that of the person standing on the opposite side of the circle; puts the crowd in a circle and sits the emperor in the middle it so he won't hear any delay from the people in the back and it sounds like a "surround" sound instead, all at the same time. About keeping them on time, I don't know, guess the court musician trained them well and we can rely on the quality of his work? Besides since they're all wearing earplugs he can just visually signal them for the tempo.








            share|improve this answer














            share|improve this answer



            share|improve this answer








            edited 22 mins ago

























            answered 1 hour ago









            S. M.

            827413




            827413












            • You're partially there. The 'science' part of the question needs to be a little more explicit.
              – chasly from UK
              1 hour ago










            • P.S. I've just realised from your answer that I missed one of the conditions out. I've added it now. Apologies. I should have thought everything through more carefully before posting.
              – chasly from UK
              1 hour ago












            • Well, I've already given the only position he can be in, which is in the center of a circle formed by the crowd, so all the sound is coming from equally distant places.
              – S. M.
              58 mins ago










            • I agree. But the reason for the earplugs is not because someone might make a mistake. Let's suppose they have all memorised everything perfectly and each practised the timing perfectly at home to a metronome.
              – chasly from UK
              26 mins ago








            • 1




              That's why I added the echo, because even if no mistakes were made there'd still be a difference in sound from the person standing next to you in the circle and the person on the opposite side of it, but I wasn't clear enough on it, I suppose. I'll edit my answer even though rhsquared's has already been accepted. Not sure "echo" would even be a correct term at all for what I meant, but it was the first thing that came to mind, my bad there.
              – S. M.
              24 mins ago




















            • You're partially there. The 'science' part of the question needs to be a little more explicit.
              – chasly from UK
              1 hour ago










            • P.S. I've just realised from your answer that I missed one of the conditions out. I've added it now. Apologies. I should have thought everything through more carefully before posting.
              – chasly from UK
              1 hour ago












            • Well, I've already given the only position he can be in, which is in the center of a circle formed by the crowd, so all the sound is coming from equally distant places.
              – S. M.
              58 mins ago










            • I agree. But the reason for the earplugs is not because someone might make a mistake. Let's suppose they have all memorised everything perfectly and each practised the timing perfectly at home to a metronome.
              – chasly from UK
              26 mins ago








            • 1




              That's why I added the echo, because even if no mistakes were made there'd still be a difference in sound from the person standing next to you in the circle and the person on the opposite side of it, but I wasn't clear enough on it, I suppose. I'll edit my answer even though rhsquared's has already been accepted. Not sure "echo" would even be a correct term at all for what I meant, but it was the first thing that came to mind, my bad there.
              – S. M.
              24 mins ago


















            You're partially there. The 'science' part of the question needs to be a little more explicit.
            – chasly from UK
            1 hour ago




            You're partially there. The 'science' part of the question needs to be a little more explicit.
            – chasly from UK
            1 hour ago












            P.S. I've just realised from your answer that I missed one of the conditions out. I've added it now. Apologies. I should have thought everything through more carefully before posting.
            – chasly from UK
            1 hour ago






            P.S. I've just realised from your answer that I missed one of the conditions out. I've added it now. Apologies. I should have thought everything through more carefully before posting.
            – chasly from UK
            1 hour ago














            Well, I've already given the only position he can be in, which is in the center of a circle formed by the crowd, so all the sound is coming from equally distant places.
            – S. M.
            58 mins ago




            Well, I've already given the only position he can be in, which is in the center of a circle formed by the crowd, so all the sound is coming from equally distant places.
            – S. M.
            58 mins ago












            I agree. But the reason for the earplugs is not because someone might make a mistake. Let's suppose they have all memorised everything perfectly and each practised the timing perfectly at home to a metronome.
            – chasly from UK
            26 mins ago






            I agree. But the reason for the earplugs is not because someone might make a mistake. Let's suppose they have all memorised everything perfectly and each practised the timing perfectly at home to a metronome.
            – chasly from UK
            26 mins ago






            1




            1




            That's why I added the echo, because even if no mistakes were made there'd still be a difference in sound from the person standing next to you in the circle and the person on the opposite side of it, but I wasn't clear enough on it, I suppose. I'll edit my answer even though rhsquared's has already been accepted. Not sure "echo" would even be a correct term at all for what I meant, but it was the first thing that came to mind, my bad there.
            – S. M.
            24 mins ago






            That's why I added the echo, because even if no mistakes were made there'd still be a difference in sound from the person standing next to you in the circle and the person on the opposite side of it, but I wasn't clear enough on it, I suppose. I'll edit my answer even though rhsquared's has already been accepted. Not sure "echo" would even be a correct term at all for what I meant, but it was the first thing that came to mind, my bad there.
            – S. M.
            24 mins ago




















            draft saved

            draft discarded




















































            Thanks for contributing an answer to Puzzling Stack Exchange!


            • Please be sure to answer the question. Provide details and share your research!

            But avoid



            • Asking for help, clarification, or responding to other answers.

            • Making statements based on opinion; back them up with references or personal experience.


            Use MathJax to format equations. MathJax reference.


            To learn more, see our tips on writing great answers.





            Some of your past answers have not been well-received, and you're in danger of being blocked from answering.


            Please pay close attention to the following guidance:


            • Please be sure to answer the question. Provide details and share your research!

            But avoid



            • Asking for help, clarification, or responding to other answers.

            • Making statements based on opinion; back them up with references or personal experience.


            To learn more, see our tips on writing great answers.




            draft saved


            draft discarded














            StackExchange.ready(
            function () {
            StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2fpuzzling.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f76438%2fwhere-does-the-emperor-sit-and-why-the-earplugs%23new-answer', 'question_page');
            }
            );

            Post as a guest















            Required, but never shown





















































            Required, but never shown














            Required, but never shown












            Required, but never shown







            Required, but never shown

































            Required, but never shown














            Required, but never shown












            Required, but never shown







            Required, but never shown







            Popular posts from this blog

            Mouse cursor on multiple screens with different PPI

            Agildo Ribeiro

            Sometime when accessing a menu: “Ubuntu 16.04 has experienced an internal error”