Can a bike have both Schrader and Presta tires?
up vote
3
down vote
favorite
I have Kona Dew 2018 and the front tire has a Presta valve while the back tire has a Schrader valve. Is it common to see bikes have different valves for each tire?
tire wheels presta schrader
New contributor
add a comment |
up vote
3
down vote
favorite
I have Kona Dew 2018 and the front tire has a Presta valve while the back tire has a Schrader valve. Is it common to see bikes have different valves for each tire?
tire wheels presta schrader
New contributor
If one wheel has a 6mm hole for a presta valve and the other has an 8mm hole for a schrader valve then you would ideally carry two spare tubes, one with each size of valve. I've done this, but ended up buying a special metal grommit from the LBS and only carrying a presta. If the other tube punctured, I would install the presta tube with the grommit.
– Criggie
yesterday
Related: bicycles.stackexchange.com/questions/10804
– Criggie
yesterday
The answer to the question "Can a bike have..." is obviously yes as you have such a bike. Asking whether this is common is different from the title of your question!
– user2705196
yesterday
add a comment |
up vote
3
down vote
favorite
up vote
3
down vote
favorite
I have Kona Dew 2018 and the front tire has a Presta valve while the back tire has a Schrader valve. Is it common to see bikes have different valves for each tire?
tire wheels presta schrader
New contributor
I have Kona Dew 2018 and the front tire has a Presta valve while the back tire has a Schrader valve. Is it common to see bikes have different valves for each tire?
tire wheels presta schrader
tire wheels presta schrader
New contributor
New contributor
New contributor
asked yesterday
Sarvesh
212
212
New contributor
New contributor
If one wheel has a 6mm hole for a presta valve and the other has an 8mm hole for a schrader valve then you would ideally carry two spare tubes, one with each size of valve. I've done this, but ended up buying a special metal grommit from the LBS and only carrying a presta. If the other tube punctured, I would install the presta tube with the grommit.
– Criggie
yesterday
Related: bicycles.stackexchange.com/questions/10804
– Criggie
yesterday
The answer to the question "Can a bike have..." is obviously yes as you have such a bike. Asking whether this is common is different from the title of your question!
– user2705196
yesterday
add a comment |
If one wheel has a 6mm hole for a presta valve and the other has an 8mm hole for a schrader valve then you would ideally carry two spare tubes, one with each size of valve. I've done this, but ended up buying a special metal grommit from the LBS and only carrying a presta. If the other tube punctured, I would install the presta tube with the grommit.
– Criggie
yesterday
Related: bicycles.stackexchange.com/questions/10804
– Criggie
yesterday
The answer to the question "Can a bike have..." is obviously yes as you have such a bike. Asking whether this is common is different from the title of your question!
– user2705196
yesterday
If one wheel has a 6mm hole for a presta valve and the other has an 8mm hole for a schrader valve then you would ideally carry two spare tubes, one with each size of valve. I've done this, but ended up buying a special metal grommit from the LBS and only carrying a presta. If the other tube punctured, I would install the presta tube with the grommit.
– Criggie
yesterday
If one wheel has a 6mm hole for a presta valve and the other has an 8mm hole for a schrader valve then you would ideally carry two spare tubes, one with each size of valve. I've done this, but ended up buying a special metal grommit from the LBS and only carrying a presta. If the other tube punctured, I would install the presta tube with the grommit.
– Criggie
yesterday
Related: bicycles.stackexchange.com/questions/10804
– Criggie
yesterday
Related: bicycles.stackexchange.com/questions/10804
– Criggie
yesterday
The answer to the question "Can a bike have..." is obviously yes as you have such a bike. Asking whether this is common is different from the title of your question!
– user2705196
yesterday
The answer to the question "Can a bike have..." is obviously yes as you have such a bike. Asking whether this is common is different from the title of your question!
– user2705196
yesterday
add a comment |
4 Answers
4
active
oldest
votes
up vote
5
down vote
accepted
Short answer, it's not common at all and probably wasn't like that when the bike was new.
The valve that you need is determined by the rim rather than the bike. If the rim is drilled out with a big enough hole for a schrader valve, then that's what you should use. If a schrader valve doesn't fit through the valve hole, then you should use a tube with presta valve. If one of the rims on the bike has been replaced (or drilled out), then they may no longer match and you would need one of each.
The more likely scenario is that at some point one of the tubes was replaced and instead of getting the correct schrader valve tube, a presta was used instead. This is easy to check as the presta valve will not fit snugly in the valve hole. If this is the case, it will work well enough in the short term, but I'd still recommend replacing it with the correct tube with a Schrader valve. Over time, the rubber around the thinner presta valve will rub against the edges of the larger diameter valve hole in the rim and eventually wear out.
New contributor
1
“Over time, the rubber around the thinner presta valve will rub against the edges of the larger diameter valve hole in the rim and eventually wear out.” Not sure if this is actually an issue. The nuts of e.g. Schwalbe Presta valve tubes are even recessed to fit in a Schrader hole.
– Michael
yesterday
1
If the rim tape is in good condition then it's unlikely to be a problem, but I've changed enough tubes with cuts around the valve to be certain that it can cause punctures.
– Carbon side up
yesterday
add a comment |
up vote
3
down vote
Why not? The bike will roll anyway. You would need two pump heads or an adapter to pump both tires, but other than that, it will work just fine.
I mean I had such setups for a while, when I had no other tubes but ones with different valves.
– Grigory Rechistov
yesterday
add a comment |
up vote
1
down vote
My hybrid currently does, and it's not a problem.
I'm switching over to presta tubes so that the same spares fit that and my tourer. That way I don't have to stock so many types of tube, especially in my commuting pannier.
The presta should be used with a spacer of some sort. I prefer a rubber grommet as the plastic parts sometimes sold for the purpose have caused me problems in the past (hard edges abrading the tube).
add a comment |
up vote
0
down vote
There's no mechanical reason why you can't have one of each. The disadvantages are purely practical.
You need a pump that can deal with both valve types, or two pumps, or to mess about with adaptors.
You need two kinds of spare tubes at home.
Most people who cycle longer distances bring a spare inner tube with them because it's much faster to replace the tube than to find and repair a puncture at the roadside (a second puncture on the same ride would need to be repaired). You could just bring a spare presta tube which will certainly get you home if you replace your Schrader tube with it.
Whether any of this is a problem for you depends on your needs and preferences.
Presta valve stems are narrower than Schrader, so you could just replace the Schrader tube with presta and then you'll only have one kind of tube. You could use an adaptor to avoid concerns about the narrow stem moving around in the wide hole.
Check the rim of your presta wheel: it might just be that somebody put a presta tube in a Schrader rim. In that case, you can replace your presta tube with the Schrader tube the rim was intended for.
If both your tubes match the rim they're installed in, you could replace the front wheel (cheaper than the back) with one that takes the same kind of valve as the back wheel. Depending on what kind of bike you have, new wheels might not be all that expensive, though I'm not sure if I'd replace one just to get the convenience of matching valves.
add a comment |
4 Answers
4
active
oldest
votes
4 Answers
4
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
up vote
5
down vote
accepted
Short answer, it's not common at all and probably wasn't like that when the bike was new.
The valve that you need is determined by the rim rather than the bike. If the rim is drilled out with a big enough hole for a schrader valve, then that's what you should use. If a schrader valve doesn't fit through the valve hole, then you should use a tube with presta valve. If one of the rims on the bike has been replaced (or drilled out), then they may no longer match and you would need one of each.
The more likely scenario is that at some point one of the tubes was replaced and instead of getting the correct schrader valve tube, a presta was used instead. This is easy to check as the presta valve will not fit snugly in the valve hole. If this is the case, it will work well enough in the short term, but I'd still recommend replacing it with the correct tube with a Schrader valve. Over time, the rubber around the thinner presta valve will rub against the edges of the larger diameter valve hole in the rim and eventually wear out.
New contributor
1
“Over time, the rubber around the thinner presta valve will rub against the edges of the larger diameter valve hole in the rim and eventually wear out.” Not sure if this is actually an issue. The nuts of e.g. Schwalbe Presta valve tubes are even recessed to fit in a Schrader hole.
– Michael
yesterday
1
If the rim tape is in good condition then it's unlikely to be a problem, but I've changed enough tubes with cuts around the valve to be certain that it can cause punctures.
– Carbon side up
yesterday
add a comment |
up vote
5
down vote
accepted
Short answer, it's not common at all and probably wasn't like that when the bike was new.
The valve that you need is determined by the rim rather than the bike. If the rim is drilled out with a big enough hole for a schrader valve, then that's what you should use. If a schrader valve doesn't fit through the valve hole, then you should use a tube with presta valve. If one of the rims on the bike has been replaced (or drilled out), then they may no longer match and you would need one of each.
The more likely scenario is that at some point one of the tubes was replaced and instead of getting the correct schrader valve tube, a presta was used instead. This is easy to check as the presta valve will not fit snugly in the valve hole. If this is the case, it will work well enough in the short term, but I'd still recommend replacing it with the correct tube with a Schrader valve. Over time, the rubber around the thinner presta valve will rub against the edges of the larger diameter valve hole in the rim and eventually wear out.
New contributor
1
“Over time, the rubber around the thinner presta valve will rub against the edges of the larger diameter valve hole in the rim and eventually wear out.” Not sure if this is actually an issue. The nuts of e.g. Schwalbe Presta valve tubes are even recessed to fit in a Schrader hole.
– Michael
yesterday
1
If the rim tape is in good condition then it's unlikely to be a problem, but I've changed enough tubes with cuts around the valve to be certain that it can cause punctures.
– Carbon side up
yesterday
add a comment |
up vote
5
down vote
accepted
up vote
5
down vote
accepted
Short answer, it's not common at all and probably wasn't like that when the bike was new.
The valve that you need is determined by the rim rather than the bike. If the rim is drilled out with a big enough hole for a schrader valve, then that's what you should use. If a schrader valve doesn't fit through the valve hole, then you should use a tube with presta valve. If one of the rims on the bike has been replaced (or drilled out), then they may no longer match and you would need one of each.
The more likely scenario is that at some point one of the tubes was replaced and instead of getting the correct schrader valve tube, a presta was used instead. This is easy to check as the presta valve will not fit snugly in the valve hole. If this is the case, it will work well enough in the short term, but I'd still recommend replacing it with the correct tube with a Schrader valve. Over time, the rubber around the thinner presta valve will rub against the edges of the larger diameter valve hole in the rim and eventually wear out.
New contributor
Short answer, it's not common at all and probably wasn't like that when the bike was new.
The valve that you need is determined by the rim rather than the bike. If the rim is drilled out with a big enough hole for a schrader valve, then that's what you should use. If a schrader valve doesn't fit through the valve hole, then you should use a tube with presta valve. If one of the rims on the bike has been replaced (or drilled out), then they may no longer match and you would need one of each.
The more likely scenario is that at some point one of the tubes was replaced and instead of getting the correct schrader valve tube, a presta was used instead. This is easy to check as the presta valve will not fit snugly in the valve hole. If this is the case, it will work well enough in the short term, but I'd still recommend replacing it with the correct tube with a Schrader valve. Over time, the rubber around the thinner presta valve will rub against the edges of the larger diameter valve hole in the rim and eventually wear out.
New contributor
New contributor
answered yesterday
Carbon side up
51619
51619
New contributor
New contributor
1
“Over time, the rubber around the thinner presta valve will rub against the edges of the larger diameter valve hole in the rim and eventually wear out.” Not sure if this is actually an issue. The nuts of e.g. Schwalbe Presta valve tubes are even recessed to fit in a Schrader hole.
– Michael
yesterday
1
If the rim tape is in good condition then it's unlikely to be a problem, but I've changed enough tubes with cuts around the valve to be certain that it can cause punctures.
– Carbon side up
yesterday
add a comment |
1
“Over time, the rubber around the thinner presta valve will rub against the edges of the larger diameter valve hole in the rim and eventually wear out.” Not sure if this is actually an issue. The nuts of e.g. Schwalbe Presta valve tubes are even recessed to fit in a Schrader hole.
– Michael
yesterday
1
If the rim tape is in good condition then it's unlikely to be a problem, but I've changed enough tubes with cuts around the valve to be certain that it can cause punctures.
– Carbon side up
yesterday
1
1
“Over time, the rubber around the thinner presta valve will rub against the edges of the larger diameter valve hole in the rim and eventually wear out.” Not sure if this is actually an issue. The nuts of e.g. Schwalbe Presta valve tubes are even recessed to fit in a Schrader hole.
– Michael
yesterday
“Over time, the rubber around the thinner presta valve will rub against the edges of the larger diameter valve hole in the rim and eventually wear out.” Not sure if this is actually an issue. The nuts of e.g. Schwalbe Presta valve tubes are even recessed to fit in a Schrader hole.
– Michael
yesterday
1
1
If the rim tape is in good condition then it's unlikely to be a problem, but I've changed enough tubes with cuts around the valve to be certain that it can cause punctures.
– Carbon side up
yesterday
If the rim tape is in good condition then it's unlikely to be a problem, but I've changed enough tubes with cuts around the valve to be certain that it can cause punctures.
– Carbon side up
yesterday
add a comment |
up vote
3
down vote
Why not? The bike will roll anyway. You would need two pump heads or an adapter to pump both tires, but other than that, it will work just fine.
I mean I had such setups for a while, when I had no other tubes but ones with different valves.
– Grigory Rechistov
yesterday
add a comment |
up vote
3
down vote
Why not? The bike will roll anyway. You would need two pump heads or an adapter to pump both tires, but other than that, it will work just fine.
I mean I had such setups for a while, when I had no other tubes but ones with different valves.
– Grigory Rechistov
yesterday
add a comment |
up vote
3
down vote
up vote
3
down vote
Why not? The bike will roll anyway. You would need two pump heads or an adapter to pump both tires, but other than that, it will work just fine.
Why not? The bike will roll anyway. You would need two pump heads or an adapter to pump both tires, but other than that, it will work just fine.
answered yesterday
Grigory Rechistov
4,144828
4,144828
I mean I had such setups for a while, when I had no other tubes but ones with different valves.
– Grigory Rechistov
yesterday
add a comment |
I mean I had such setups for a while, when I had no other tubes but ones with different valves.
– Grigory Rechistov
yesterday
I mean I had such setups for a while, when I had no other tubes but ones with different valves.
– Grigory Rechistov
yesterday
I mean I had such setups for a while, when I had no other tubes but ones with different valves.
– Grigory Rechistov
yesterday
add a comment |
up vote
1
down vote
My hybrid currently does, and it's not a problem.
I'm switching over to presta tubes so that the same spares fit that and my tourer. That way I don't have to stock so many types of tube, especially in my commuting pannier.
The presta should be used with a spacer of some sort. I prefer a rubber grommet as the plastic parts sometimes sold for the purpose have caused me problems in the past (hard edges abrading the tube).
add a comment |
up vote
1
down vote
My hybrid currently does, and it's not a problem.
I'm switching over to presta tubes so that the same spares fit that and my tourer. That way I don't have to stock so many types of tube, especially in my commuting pannier.
The presta should be used with a spacer of some sort. I prefer a rubber grommet as the plastic parts sometimes sold for the purpose have caused me problems in the past (hard edges abrading the tube).
add a comment |
up vote
1
down vote
up vote
1
down vote
My hybrid currently does, and it's not a problem.
I'm switching over to presta tubes so that the same spares fit that and my tourer. That way I don't have to stock so many types of tube, especially in my commuting pannier.
The presta should be used with a spacer of some sort. I prefer a rubber grommet as the plastic parts sometimes sold for the purpose have caused me problems in the past (hard edges abrading the tube).
My hybrid currently does, and it's not a problem.
I'm switching over to presta tubes so that the same spares fit that and my tourer. That way I don't have to stock so many types of tube, especially in my commuting pannier.
The presta should be used with a spacer of some sort. I prefer a rubber grommet as the plastic parts sometimes sold for the purpose have caused me problems in the past (hard edges abrading the tube).
answered yesterday
Chris H
21.3k13399
21.3k13399
add a comment |
add a comment |
up vote
0
down vote
There's no mechanical reason why you can't have one of each. The disadvantages are purely practical.
You need a pump that can deal with both valve types, or two pumps, or to mess about with adaptors.
You need two kinds of spare tubes at home.
Most people who cycle longer distances bring a spare inner tube with them because it's much faster to replace the tube than to find and repair a puncture at the roadside (a second puncture on the same ride would need to be repaired). You could just bring a spare presta tube which will certainly get you home if you replace your Schrader tube with it.
Whether any of this is a problem for you depends on your needs and preferences.
Presta valve stems are narrower than Schrader, so you could just replace the Schrader tube with presta and then you'll only have one kind of tube. You could use an adaptor to avoid concerns about the narrow stem moving around in the wide hole.
Check the rim of your presta wheel: it might just be that somebody put a presta tube in a Schrader rim. In that case, you can replace your presta tube with the Schrader tube the rim was intended for.
If both your tubes match the rim they're installed in, you could replace the front wheel (cheaper than the back) with one that takes the same kind of valve as the back wheel. Depending on what kind of bike you have, new wheels might not be all that expensive, though I'm not sure if I'd replace one just to get the convenience of matching valves.
add a comment |
up vote
0
down vote
There's no mechanical reason why you can't have one of each. The disadvantages are purely practical.
You need a pump that can deal with both valve types, or two pumps, or to mess about with adaptors.
You need two kinds of spare tubes at home.
Most people who cycle longer distances bring a spare inner tube with them because it's much faster to replace the tube than to find and repair a puncture at the roadside (a second puncture on the same ride would need to be repaired). You could just bring a spare presta tube which will certainly get you home if you replace your Schrader tube with it.
Whether any of this is a problem for you depends on your needs and preferences.
Presta valve stems are narrower than Schrader, so you could just replace the Schrader tube with presta and then you'll only have one kind of tube. You could use an adaptor to avoid concerns about the narrow stem moving around in the wide hole.
Check the rim of your presta wheel: it might just be that somebody put a presta tube in a Schrader rim. In that case, you can replace your presta tube with the Schrader tube the rim was intended for.
If both your tubes match the rim they're installed in, you could replace the front wheel (cheaper than the back) with one that takes the same kind of valve as the back wheel. Depending on what kind of bike you have, new wheels might not be all that expensive, though I'm not sure if I'd replace one just to get the convenience of matching valves.
add a comment |
up vote
0
down vote
up vote
0
down vote
There's no mechanical reason why you can't have one of each. The disadvantages are purely practical.
You need a pump that can deal with both valve types, or two pumps, or to mess about with adaptors.
You need two kinds of spare tubes at home.
Most people who cycle longer distances bring a spare inner tube with them because it's much faster to replace the tube than to find and repair a puncture at the roadside (a second puncture on the same ride would need to be repaired). You could just bring a spare presta tube which will certainly get you home if you replace your Schrader tube with it.
Whether any of this is a problem for you depends on your needs and preferences.
Presta valve stems are narrower than Schrader, so you could just replace the Schrader tube with presta and then you'll only have one kind of tube. You could use an adaptor to avoid concerns about the narrow stem moving around in the wide hole.
Check the rim of your presta wheel: it might just be that somebody put a presta tube in a Schrader rim. In that case, you can replace your presta tube with the Schrader tube the rim was intended for.
If both your tubes match the rim they're installed in, you could replace the front wheel (cheaper than the back) with one that takes the same kind of valve as the back wheel. Depending on what kind of bike you have, new wheels might not be all that expensive, though I'm not sure if I'd replace one just to get the convenience of matching valves.
There's no mechanical reason why you can't have one of each. The disadvantages are purely practical.
You need a pump that can deal with both valve types, or two pumps, or to mess about with adaptors.
You need two kinds of spare tubes at home.
Most people who cycle longer distances bring a spare inner tube with them because it's much faster to replace the tube than to find and repair a puncture at the roadside (a second puncture on the same ride would need to be repaired). You could just bring a spare presta tube which will certainly get you home if you replace your Schrader tube with it.
Whether any of this is a problem for you depends on your needs and preferences.
Presta valve stems are narrower than Schrader, so you could just replace the Schrader tube with presta and then you'll only have one kind of tube. You could use an adaptor to avoid concerns about the narrow stem moving around in the wide hole.
Check the rim of your presta wheel: it might just be that somebody put a presta tube in a Schrader rim. In that case, you can replace your presta tube with the Schrader tube the rim was intended for.
If both your tubes match the rim they're installed in, you could replace the front wheel (cheaper than the back) with one that takes the same kind of valve as the back wheel. Depending on what kind of bike you have, new wheels might not be all that expensive, though I'm not sure if I'd replace one just to get the convenience of matching valves.
answered yesterday
David Richerby
9,34523050
9,34523050
add a comment |
add a comment |
Sarvesh is a new contributor. Be nice, and check out our Code of Conduct.
Sarvesh is a new contributor. Be nice, and check out our Code of Conduct.
Sarvesh is a new contributor. Be nice, and check out our Code of Conduct.
Sarvesh is a new contributor. Be nice, and check out our Code of Conduct.
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function () {
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
});
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
StackExchange.ready(
function () {
StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2fbicycles.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f58139%2fcan-a-bike-have-both-schrader-and-presta-tires%23new-answer', 'question_page');
}
);
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function () {
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
});
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function () {
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
});
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function () {
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
});
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
If one wheel has a 6mm hole for a presta valve and the other has an 8mm hole for a schrader valve then you would ideally carry two spare tubes, one with each size of valve. I've done this, but ended up buying a special metal grommit from the LBS and only carrying a presta. If the other tube punctured, I would install the presta tube with the grommit.
– Criggie
yesterday
Related: bicycles.stackexchange.com/questions/10804
– Criggie
yesterday
The answer to the question "Can a bike have..." is obviously yes as you have such a bike. Asking whether this is common is different from the title of your question!
– user2705196
yesterday